Eighty percent of transfers exceed two-hour limit; but seriously injured are moved faster
MAYWOOD, Ill. – Illinois law requires that when hospitals need to transfer trauma patients to centers with higher levels of trauma care, such transfers should be made within two hours.
However, a new study, published in the December issue of the Archives of Surgery, finds that 80 percent of transfer cases took longer than two hours. However, the most seriously injured patients did seem to more quickly reach the level of care that best met their medical needs within two hours.
“The two-hour rule is only complied with 20 percent of the time,” said trauma surgeon Dr. Thomas Esposito, chief of the Division of Trauma, Surgical Critical Care and Burns in the Department of Surgery at Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine and a co-author of the study. “Eighty percent of the time the transfer occurs more than two hours after the arrival at the first hospital.”
The study examines data from the Illinois Trauma Registry from 1999 to 2003. During that period, 22,447 transfers of trauma patients occurred between facilities in the state, a transfer rate of 10.4 percent. Of those, 4,502 transfers (20 percent) took place within two hours. The median time for the remaining transfers was 2 hours and 21 minutes. The data cover 50 to 60 percent of transfer cases from 64 trauma centers in Illinois.
The study found that the patients who were transferred within two hours were more severely injured and more commonly underwent same-day surgery. These patients in the same set were more likely to die but the mortality rate for patients transferred after more than two hours matched those of all other trauma patients.
“We looked at some markers of severity that caused us to conclude, “Guess what? Regardless of the rule, what appears to be is the sickest patients do get transferred within the two-hour window and the people who aren’t so sick are the ones who don’t necessarily get there in two hours but that’s probably because they don’t need to,’” Esposito said.
The patients most commonly transferred were those with head and orthopaedic injuries, which could be due to shortages of medical specialists that treat those conditions, the study found. Also, self-paying patients were more likely to be transferred within two hours versus other same-day transfers or all other trauma patients.
“This seems to be an unfortunate national trend, not limited to Illinois, which represents a serious deficit in the emergency-care workforce, and that needs to be addressed,” Esposito said.
The study concludes that the two-hour directive isn’t cost-efficient because it does not lead to better patient outcomes.
“Our theory is that that two-hour rule should be abandoned and that emergency department physicians or trauma surgeons at the first hospital are smart enough without a rule to get the right patient to the right place in the right amount of time,” Esposito said. “That’s the mantra or the fundamental philosophy of trauma systems.”
Loyola University Health System’s (Loyola) hospital is designated by the state of Illinois as a Level I Trauma Center for both adult and pediatric patients. Additionally, the American College of Surgeons (ACS) also has verified the hospital’s Level I Trauma Center status. Loyola is the only hospital in Illinois — and one of a select group nationwide — to earn that distinction.
Co-authors of the study are Dr. Richard L. Gamelli, dean of the Stritch School of Medicine; Dr. Frederick A. Luchette, professor of surgery, Division of General Surgery, Stritch; Dr. Robert Lawrence Reed, Clarian Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis; and Dr. Marie L. Crandall, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University in Chicago.
Loyola University Health System (LUHS) is a member of Trinity Health. Based in the western suburbs of Chicago, LUHS is a quaternary care system with a 61-acre main medical center campus, the 36-acre Gottlieb Memorial Hospital campus and more than 30 primary and specialty care facilities in Cook, Will and DuPage counties. The medical center campus is conveniently located in Maywood, 13 miles west of the Chicago Loop and 8 miles east of Oak Brook, Ill. The heart of the medical center campus, Loyola University Hospital, is a 569-licensed-bed facility. It houses a Level 1 Trauma Center, a Burn Center and the Ronald McDonald® Children’s Hospital of Loyola University Medical Center. Also on campus are the Cardinal Bernardin Cancer Center, Loyola Outpatient Center, Center for Heart & Vascular Medicine and Loyola Oral Health Center as well as the LUC Stritch School of Medicine, the LUC Marcella Niehoff School of Nursing and the Loyola Center for Fitness. Loyola's Gottlieb campus in Melrose Park includes the 264-licensed-bed community hospital, the Professional Office Building housing 150 private practice clinics, the Adult Day Care, the Gottlieb Center for Fitness, Loyola Center for Metabolic Surgery and Bariatric Care and the Loyola Cancer Care & Research at the Marjorie G. Weinberg Cancer Center at Melrose Park.